Visit our site to find reviews on buckeyes ice cream. We have the top best buckeyes ice cream comparison 2026 and you can make an informed decision!
That’s why we’ve taken 76059 reviews from top experts and organized them according to our rankings for you.
Bestseller No. 1
Anthony-Thomas, Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes in Ohio State Buckeyes Box, Deliciously Delightful Snacks (12 Count) - Premium Quality Chocolate Buckeyes: These high quality Anthony Thomas peanut butter and milk chocolate buckeyes are made with only the highest quality ingredients for the best indulgent flavor!
- Perfect Gift: This beautiful pack contains 60 individually wrapped buckeyes candies and it is perfect for guests, weddings, birthdays, graduation parties, tailgate parties or simply you can enjoy this as a treat for yourself.
- Melt in Your Mouth: These chocolate peanut butter buckeye candies are made with creamy peanut butter, chocolate and milk so these buckeye candies will melt in your mouth in seconds.
- Delicious Snack: Enjoy them straight out of the box as a snack or add them as a topping to frozen yogurt and ice cream!
- A Fan Favorite: These yummy peanut butter chocolate buckeye candies are so delicious and delightful that everyone will love.
Bestseller No. 2
Anthony Thomas, Great Tasting Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes in Regular Box, Deliciously Delightful Snacks (24 Count) - Premium Quality: These high quality Anthony Thomas peanut butter and milk chocolate buckeyes are made with only the highest quality ingredients for the best indulgent flavor!
- A Perfect Gift: This beautiful pack contains 24 individual buckeyes candy and it is perfect for guests, weddings, birthdays, graduation parties, and tailgate parties!
- Melt in Your Mouth: These chocolate peanut butter buckeye candies are made with creamy peanut butter, chocolate, and milk so these buckeye candies will melt in your mouth in seconds!
- A Delightful Snack: Enjoy them straight out of the box as a snack or add them as a topping to frozen yogurt and ice cream!
- A Classic Favorite: These buckeyes have been a fan favorite since we our family owned chocolate business in 1932!
Bestseller No. 3
Marsha's Buckeyes 50-Count Tub - HOMEMADE RECIPE: Our buckeyes are made from our delicious homemade family recipe made by Marsha Smith herself!
- A GLUTEN FREE snack
- Great for having parties and sharing with friends and family. Share while watching sporting events or having holiday parties.
- Perfect for baking other goodies with or enjoying them on their own
- Plastic compact packaging for easy and minimal storage space
Bestseller No. 4
Anthony Thomas, Great Tasting Peanut Butter & Milk Chocolate Buckeyes in Ohio State Buckeyes Box, Deliciously Delightful Snacks, (6 Count) - Premium Quality Chocolate Buckeyes: These high quality Anthony Thomas peanut butter and milk chocolate buckeyes are made with only the highest quality ingredients for the best indulgent flavor!
- Perfect Gift: This beautiful pack contains 6 individual buckeyes candy and it is perfect for guests, weddings, birthdays, graduation parties, tailgate parties or simply you can enjoy this as a treat for yourself.
- Melt in Your Mouth: These chocolate peanut butter buckeye candies are made with creamy peanut butter, chocolate and milk so these buckeye candies will melt in your mouth in seconds.
- Delicious Snack: Enjoy them straight out of the box as a snack or add them as a topping to frozen yogurt and ice cream!
- A Fan Favorite: These yummy peanut butter chocolate buckeye candies are a delicious and delightful treat that everyone will love.
Bestseller No. 5
Uncle Butch's Fudge – Gourmet Chocolate Buckeyes – Handcrafted Holiday Treat with Peanut Butter Fudge Centre – Artisan Creamy Texture – Premium Christmas Gift Box for Holidays – 24 Count - HANDCRAFTED SWEETNESS: Each batch of Uncle Butch’s fudge is made by master artisans using traditional small-batch methods to achieve superior creaminess, texture, and flavor. No mass production. Just real, old-fashioned craftsmanship in every piece
- A TOUCH OF CHRISTMAS MAGIC: Each buckeye has a decadent semisweet chocolate coating wrapped around a silky peanut butter center for a well-rounded taste experience. A delicious sweet delight you can bite or nibble on, ideal for the holidays
- A FESTIVE HOLIDAY TREAT: Experience the magic of the holidays in every piece with this Christmas fudge gift box! Delicious, irresistible, and mouth-watering gourmet fudge, a seasonal delight for sharing and enjoying with your loved ones
- ULTIMATE CONFECTIONERY QUALITY: Made with premium chocolate and real butter for an indulgent melt-in-your-mouth texture and flavor. Arrives fresh and ready to serve straight from the box, where each bite is a journey your taste buds will love
- ALLERGEN INFORMATION: Uncle Butch's Fudge is made with all fresh ingredients. All of our fudge may contain trace amounts of nuts, milk proteins, egg, gluten, and peanuts that are used at our facility. Enjoy with awareness
Bestseller No. 6
Marsha's Buckeyes Individually Wrapped (60 Per Case) - HOMEMADE RECIPE: Our buckeyes are made from our delicious homemade family recipe made by Marsha Smith herself!
- A GLUTEN FREE snack
- Great for parties and sharing with friends & family
- Individually wrapped pieces of gluten free candy buckeyes for easy handling
- Perfect for baking other goodies with or enjoying them on their own
Bestseller No. 7
Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes (1lb Resealable Zip Lock Stand Up Bag) - MINI MILK CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER BUCKEYES: The Bulk-Priced Food Shoppe’s mini milk chocolate peanut butter buckeyes are a sweet treat! Smaller, bit-size variation of the original buckeyes.
- TASTE: The smooth, melty texture of these buckeyes will have you coming back for another handful. Peanut butter and milk chocolate -- do we need to say more?
- FRESHNESS: Freshness of our products are always guaranteed due to in-house packaging. Bulk shipments are delivered weekly to our warehouse for the best possible quality.
- PACKAGING: Packaged and heat-sealed in a state licensed facility to ensure quality and cleanliness. Product comes in a resealable, stand-up bag.
- COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: United States – The Bulk-Priced Food Shoppe buys in bulk so YOU don’t have to! We give our customers the freshest food at the best possible price.
Bestseller No. 9
Marsha's Buckeyes Deli Containers (12 Buckeyes Per Container, 4 Containers Per Order) - Convenient Size: 12 buckeyes per container, perfect for sharing or gifting.
- Bulk Value: 4 containers per order ensure you’re stocked up for any occasion.
- Rich Flavor: Signature combination of smooth peanut butter and dark chocolate.
- Perfect for Parties: Great for serving at events, gatherings, or family meals.
- Fresh and Ready to Serve: Comes in easy-to-use deli containers that keep buckeyes fresh and ready to enjoy.
Bestseller No. 10
Mini Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeyes (1lb Resealable Zip Lock Stand Up Bag) - MINI DARK CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER BUCKEYES: The Bulk-Priced Food Shoppe’s mini dark chocolate peanut butter buckeyes are a sweet treat! Smaller, bit-size variation of the original buckeyes.
- TASTE: The smooth, melty texture of these buckeyes will have you coming back for another handful. Peanut butter and dark chocolate -- do we need to say more?
- FRESHNESS: Freshness of our products are always guaranteed due to in-house packaging. Bulk shipments are delivered weekly to our warehouse for the best possible quality.
- PACKAGING: Packaged and heat-sealed in a state licensed facility to ensure quality and cleanliness. Product comes in a resealable, stand-up bag.
- COUNTRY OF ORIGIN: United States – The Bulk-Priced Food Shoppe buys in bulk so YOU don’t have to! We give our customers the freshest food at the best possible price.
With our guide, you can find the best buckeyes ice cream available on the e-commerce market. We make use of Big Data and AI data to compile this list, so it is highly accurate.
The process of creating this content was challenging, but our team persevered through it to bring you the best possible results. We read user reviews and look at what buyers think about each product so that your buying experience will be satisfying.
